Monday, June 6, 2011

D Day: I honor my father, a brave Jewish American GI in World War II

Nathan Litvin
Jewish American GI
from Mount Clemens, Michigan
above on left, at Utah Beach, after D-Day, 1944 in Normandy.

Sir Martin Gilbert stated on the back cover of his book  D-Day--
"The Allied landings in 1944 had all the prospects for disaster. Churchill thought he would be woken up to be told of massive casualties. Eisenhower prepared a somber broadcast announcing that the enterprise had failed
The specter of failure was always present. After a failed landing the Nazi regime would have regained the ascendant. New, terrifying bombs and rockets were ready to be launched. Long-distance submarines were in the final stage of development. The last million Jews of Europe were listed for deportation and death.
Failure at Normandy could have given Hitler the chance of continuing to rule western Europe, particularly if the United States, bloodied and defeated  in Normandy, had decided -- after two and a half years of focusing on Europe -- to turn all its energies to the ever-growing demands of the Pacific, leaving Europe to its own devices. Had that happened, I doubt if I would have been alive to write this book, or free to express my opinions without fear of arrest."
Nathan Litvin was my father. I remember my father as a hero, a brave Jewish American GI. He met my mother, an Auschwitz survivor, in Munich, Germany after liberation. He has been gone from this earth for eighteen (Chai) years. Now, my mother has been gone for six weeks and they are reunited.

An excellent book and a fascinating read is D-Day, by Sir Martin Gilbert.

Martin Gilbert has kindly contributed one of the maps from D-Day and a foreword to my book We Never Lost Hope: A Holocaust Memoir and Love Story.


  1. It's hard to call this one, isn't it?

    American author Colin Heaton did some alternative history exercises in Night Fighter, a history of the air-war over Europe that he wrote with Anne-Marie Lewis, and concluded that if Bomber Command had failed to prevent a German invasion of the UK before Pearl Harbor, the US might have stayed out of the war longer, but would have been forced to act because Hitler wouldn't have been satisfied at staying within European shores. For example, as Heaton says, at one time Hitler's plans demanded control of 90% of the world's oil supplies.

    But if D-Day had failed? I don't know. I guess it would all have hinged upon whether Hitler reamined true to his Axis agreements with Japan and Italy to make war upon any power who declared war with them. For reasons unknown, it was the only major treaty he honoured.

  2. Sounds like a really good read! Here it is on Amazon
    Thank you Frugal, for such a thoughtful and interesting comment! Cheers!